Kristopher
| | | In case I did not make it clear, once the list of nominations is consolidated, the nominated levels will hopefully be added to the Hall of Fame in the tenth offical levelpack. |
|
bones
| | | does it show on the page who nominated them?? if so it might not be a good thing cause popularity could play a part |
|
Kristopher
| | | Yes, it does.
The original nominations were done privately, so they were unaffected by popularity. Now, it is good to show popularity, because if a level was selected by three different people, then it must be good, and people should consider that level more. |
|
Kristopher
| | | I added a voting form to the page. Now each level has "Vote Yes" and "Vote no" options. (This is the best way to select the best levels on the page, because you can vote on all of the levels without having to load a different web page for each level). Once you have voted for every level, you can go to the bottom of the page, and submit all of your votes at once. If at least 5 people can vote on all of the levels, I can probably pair the list down quite easily. |
|
mike flips
| | | need a "maybe" option to select, as in, if there arent enough for sures, its a backup level to go in. |
|
Kristopher
| | | If you want to vote "Maybe," then vote "No." People should vote "No" on 2/3 of the levels, because if people keep voting "Yes" and "Maybe", then the list won't be consolidated. |
|
Kristopher
| | |
Vega
| | |
mike flips
| | | I didnt like christmas that much...
i voted for about half the levels because it was really really slow. |
|
Kristopher
| | | After the page loads, it should be quite fast - click to vote, then click [Down to Next Level].
All votes are listed here:
http://bikeordie.50we bs.com/misc/votes.txt
|
|
bones
| | | i just voted for all levels since i couldnt sleep and i think a 1,2,3 thing would be better for things like this. also a chat on bod to discuss the order of the levels when they are established will be needed
p.s. kris i have firefox on all computer |
|
Vega
| | |
Vega
| | | Kris is anyone else going to be voting? We need more of a spread here. I think at least 10 voters isn't to much to ask for. Having only 4-5 people voting for these seems too personal. By the way, please please don't take my comments as a slam against any of the people that have made these levels. From my recent time invested and experience in creating levels, I know each level takes time to create. All levels nominated have some value |
|
Kristopher
| | |
Vega
| | | I voted for every level and now that I think about it, I wish I would have done a 'no vote' for a few. I like that a no vote is one negative point because it's a way for you to opt out if you don't have a strong opinion of that particular level. This would be more pure because an undecided opinion should not weigh as much as a strong opinion and then all actual votes would reflect more accurate ratings since that person would have had to really want the level to put yes and really NOT want it to put no. I am going to go back and redo my votes with this in mind |
|
Kristopher
| | |
Vega
| | | the only thing I would change is that a 'yes' should equal +5 points |
|
PMD
| | 5 | | | 6 | |
| | | I think one of the problems with the voting is that I we are most likely voting without playing the level. It would help if we could see a replay of someone playing the level (like you supplied Kristopher), or a level pack we could download that had them all in one pack, so we could try them out without downloading and finding every level.
I know that I didn't vote for many of them because I was just not sure how it would play or how long the levels might be. I don't want another Cave Dweller. |
|
PMD
| | 5 | | | 6 | |
| | | Doublepost--sorry. Maybe we could divide up the the levels amongst us (so we don't have to play them all) and play them, make a recording of them, and send the recordings to Kristopher to post. It would make it a lot easier to make a decision on a level and vote.
Without it, it is like voting on a political candidate with only looking at their picture and not seeing how they operate. |
|
Vega
| | | PMD, you have a great idea. Kris and I actually discussed this same idea a couple of weeks ago. Kris - Is there a way these could be downloaded in one level pack? (or split into 2 or 3 since there are so many). If not, I will gladly play a handful and submit them.
I'll play and submit to Kris the following:
Christmas
Welcome to the Jungle
Imola
Suzuka
Pit and the Pendelum
Like a glove
So close to so far
House Storming
Alphabet
Keep in mind there are several levels that are already viewable......Dante's, Ice Skating, and all of the levels that Kris put replays out on the temp pages!
|
|