Actually, Bottle (Rachman, 11/7/04) and Shelf (DavidKing, 2/27/06) are older. However, I would argue that they don't count since there is no physical way to beat these times. Your run on The Right Way is the oldest "non-bottle" gold. Congrats!
That's really neat to see, looks like 2008 was the best year as far as that goes. I wonder what the peak was, when we had the most active players at one time I mean. I feel like at some points it has been as few as six or seven, while others it has been more than 20 people commenting and submitting games.